Re: SetData & ContentRef

Klaus Hofrichter (Hofrichter@fokus.gmd.de)
Thu, 22 Jan 1998 10:49:20 +0100

Guillaume,

here is a partial answer:
> Would not it be simplier to extend the SetVariable action to take into
> account OctetString <-> ContentRef conversions?
> Should not this be addressed by the MHEG-5 Maintainance Task Force?

I would have prefered to have cast operations natively in MHEG5. It can
definitvely be on the issues list of the MHEG 5 MTF.

However, my first word on that would be that this is a serious change in
MHEG and therefore there should be very good reasons to do so, and there
should be broad acceptance.

I would rate that serious, since potential existing engines have already
implemented the DAVIC ResProgs (or others) to do that. Therefor, such change
would introduce the risk of inportability.
But if the MTF rats that different, I would be happy.

Any other opinions on that important issue, please?

- Klaus

-- 
GMD FOKUS    German National Research Center for Information Technology
Klaus Hofrichter    Kaiserin-Augusta-Allee 31  D-10589 Berlin   Germany
mailto:hofrichter@fokus.gmd.de   http://www.fokus.gmd.de/usr/hofrichter
P: +49 30 3463 7211  Fx -8211  There is a reexamination, but no reparty